I totally agree with your points. BC was not a good fit for the part period and I really think they shafted fans of TOS and Trek by bringing him on board for Khan and rehashing one of the most iconic scenes in Trek history. I really hope the next one tries to get back to a more philosophical approach during the five year mission. I'm sure they won't, especially not if JJ comes back, but I am still going to hope for the best.

I really do love all the crew interactions in the movie though so I'll definitely watch it again once it's on video for that stuff. Ha even in the theater I immediately ignored BC's lines after he said he was Khan.