February 2023

S M T W T F S
   12 34
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728    

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Friday, December 27th, 2013 03:45 pm
Fandom Tennis Match Meme:

Okay, here's how this is going to work. You comment with a fandom question. I answer it and then ask you a question that has some thematic relevance to the question you asked me.


 photo stock6BFHV2vi61usJVNUt3Efm2_zpsce5df805.gif
Tags:
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 12:53 am (UTC)
Who is your favorite Bird of Prey?
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 02:27 am (UTC)
Too hard to pick? There are a bunch of them, so top 3 or 5 or whatever would work too.

(unless that's not what you meant? I have a very defective sarcasm detector.)
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 03:19 am (UTC)
That is totally what I meant. And for me, when i hear Birds of Prey, I think Helena Bertinelli, Oracle, and Black Canary. Black Canary and Oracle are both characters I love and feel really protective of after the bullshit that they've gone through at the hands of various writes BUT i also really like Helena and she had SUCH A SOLID book (it's actually on my best books of 2013) so part of me is tempted to pick her.

For you: favorite (canon) superhero team up.
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 03:26 am (UTC)
Those are definitely solid BoP picks. I'm sad because my library doesn't have ANY of the old Birds of Prey, so I have only read a few issues of it, and Dinah especially I hardly know at all. (I have read the first two volumes of the reboot series, which started off great and then kind of spiraled downward.)

That's a hard one! I think my favorite is Batgirls & Robins in general, and maybe baby Dick and Babs in particular, by a very narrow margin.
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 09:42 pm (UTC)
I've like what I've seen of Dinah, and what's really struck me about her is how EASY she seems to be to do right and how badly live action has handled her character.
Sunday, December 29th, 2013 12:27 am (UTC)
Dinah is a smart, funny, master martial artist who is sometimes dating/married to Green Arrow. Birds of Prey made her an inept, teenage psychic, Arrow fumbled around for an entire season before finally managing to get a version of her correct (even though the names are different), and I feel like there was another example of live action doing very badly with her character.
Sunday, December 29th, 2013 01:16 am (UTC)
Birds of Prey made her an inept, teenage psychic
That does seem like a pretty epic fumble.
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 08:07 pm (UTC)
Which of the Avengers - current movie-verse - do you think has the potential to go to the dark side and become a full on villain? For which of them do you think that story arc would work best?

And, inversely, do you think Loki has the potential to be a hero? (Potential, not necessarily realistic storyline.)
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 09:42 pm (UTC)
do you think has the potential to go to the dark side and become a full on villain? For which of them do you think that story arc would work best?

All of them, really, but I would be MOST satisfied with Tony Stark becoming a villain. I think he has the appropriate hubris and intelligence and could go down quiet a dark path, thinking the entire time that he's in control and that he's doing what's best and that he's being a hero.

And, inversely, do you think Loki has the potential to be a hero? (Potential, not necessarily realistic storyline.)

Abso-fucking-lutely. I think we've actually seen flashes of this throughout both Thor movies.


Natasha Romanoff gets a movie - what would you like that to look like?
Saturday, December 28th, 2013 11:23 pm (UTC)
Epic, with a side of vengeance.

I feel like Natasha has a lot of potential to develop emotionally - she's obviously been through hell and she's guarded because of that - but I think we could see her learn to find more of a balance between badass warrior chick and the other aspects of her personality. I don't like the sort of culturally embedded idea that strong women - autonomous, capable, in control, etc. - only deserve the title if they do absolutely everything on their own, without ever relying on anyone else. It doesn't have to be romantic at all - friendship with Pepper would be awesome - but I'd like to see her gain some self-awareness, that caring about other people and even letting them in a little, doesn't necessarily make her weak.

Plot-wise, I think I'd really like to see something with a Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead take on things or Xander in the episode The Zeppo on Buffy - while the super-powered heroes are off doing flashy, apocalypse-diverting shit, the movie would intersperse brief mentions of that while we follow Natasha behind the scenes, just doing her job and getting shit done, and seeing the real impact of what it's like being a superhero without superpowers. The climax should be more subtle than standard, too - not big, city-destroying, in-your-face action, but Black Widow kicking some serious ass (initially without backup) - which hinges around stopping something (like a doomsday device, etc.), that if not stopped, would have world-changing consequences, but since she manages to stop it, it's just kind of over without a huge fuss and we get to see that it's just another day at the office for her.

Also, Hawkeye would need to have a role in it - but not a huge one. I think their relationship works best as subtext, but I'd like to learn more about how they came to trust each other so much and really cement their dynamic. I think Hawkeye should have a solid presence in the movie, but for most of it he'd be off on his own mission. If he were to appear in the climax at all, Natasha would have called him earlier, thinking she's not going to survive what's coming, and that conversation would be all mission-oriented but with so much subtext, and he'd be saying, don't do anything stupid, to which she'd reply, got to get the job done, and he'd understand, exactly, because he's like that too, and then they'd mention some past mission they were on together, in which it's vaguely insinuated that they had some sort of moment, and then they'd trail off and they'd both be trying to be all stoic and emotionless but not quite succeeding, and their silence would say everything without saying anything at all.

And then Natasha would get to a point in the climax where she's practically out of ammo and she's hurt and surrounded and then Hawkeye would show up, and she'd ask him (mockingly) if he's there to save her, to which he'd reply that he wouldn't dare, whilst shooting a bad guy about to kill her, then he stays to hold off the horde of minions whilst she goes to stop the doomsday machine or whatever and he tells her he's got her back, while she's off saving the world.

Then the movie would end with Natasha out with Pepper, drinking vodka shots and having a girls' night, and she'd get a call from Hawkeye, saying he's off on another mission to whatever city, telling her it wouldn't hurt to have someone else along to watch his back, but it would end before the audience sees if she decides to join him or not.

Plus, I want a scene where she tortures someone.


Wow, that turned out a lot more involved than I expected. I wasn't aware I even had an opinion on the subject.
Friday, January 10th, 2014 05:29 am (UTC)
I would love a Natasha-centric movie that worked off the premise that she regularly saves the world. I loved the way that Hawkeye’s character in the Avengers was used to illuminate Natasha’s feelings and pov, so I would like to see that relationship developed more, even if I don’t want it to be explicitly romantic either.

I could not disagree more about the torture. Torture is extremely unreliable and is a tool that is utterly beneath Natasha Romanoff. Natasha has a billion more reliable ways of gathering information, and most of which involve making people think SHE is the vulnerable, in-peril person, or that she is on their side. Which is about a thousand times more badass and more ethical than ripping someone’s fingernails out.