So, the stealth darkhorse thing that I didn't expect to be enjoying is Brooklyn Nine-Nine, which I just find REALLY entertaining.
It's a solid comedy and I'm such a fan of police procedurals that I really feel like I kinda get the in-jokes. (Also, there is comedy gold waiting when the show decides to mock will they/won't they pairings with Santiago and the main dude whose name I can't remember.)
I like that pretty much every person is a source for comedy in different ways, and that the vast majority of the time it isn't mean spirited comedy.
I just finished watching the ME episode (I have watched the aired episodes totally out of order) and I dig how the comedy of the entire episode is basically what a dick the main character is. You won't believe it - the main character is a talented dick and everyone treats him like a talented dick! (And considering he and Santiago are neck-and-neck, he's clearly not a genius on a different level than everyone else.)
Also! This show totally passes the Bechdel test.
Also, I may be shipping Diaz/Boyle which I am fairly sure I am not okay with.