Zetta Elliot wrote
a guest post on Justine Larbalestier's blog. Now, there is a hell of a lot to unpack and discuss in her post but I'm going to focus on one part of that which I feels relates directly to me, as an aspiring author:
"I must confess that lately, the only white-authored books I read are those about people of color. I sometimes feel obligated to read these books in order to ascertain whether or not black people are being misrepresented by white authors who mean well, but don’t really have a clue. I generally expect white authors to get it wrong, but sometimes they do surprise me (Liar would be one example; Octavian Nothing Vol. 1 is another) so it’s important to keep an open mind. Mostly I just wish white authors would leave people of color alone. I appreciate their desire to be inclusive, but statistics compiled by the Cooperative Children’s Book Center show that there are more books about African Americans than by African Americans."
Now, I totally relate to how Elliot feels on an emotional level (and probably would feel the same way in her shoes) but as someone who does want to write CoC and be more inclusive, it's quite frustrating. Does me writing a book with black characters prevent a black author from getting published? If CoC are unrepresented in mainstream fiction, especially sci fi and fantasy, wouldn't having CoC, even if written by someone white, make it MORE likely for young people of color to feel enouraged about writing or make publishes more likely to accept books with CoC?
Now, I'm not positive the answer to all of these questions is 'yes' but I keeps like Elliot is requesting that we keep the status quo, quo, which... doesn't seem to be doing much for equality.